Amazon.com Widgets

Subscribe to my Blog
There She Grows

How Timeouts Sometimes Work for Us

March 16th, 2010

How Timeouts Sometimes Work for Us

We’ve all heard of time-outs as one of those standard issue parenting techniques that have stood the test of time throughout generations. Now that I’m a parent myself I’ve learned that time-outs don’t mean the same thing to all parents or all kids. When, how and why parents resort to time-outs and the ‘ground rules’ that surround them are surely as varied as parents and kids are varied.

Lately I’ve heard some talk from the attachment-parenting set (something I’ve considered myself a part of in many ways, go figure) that time-outs are in fact a detrimental no-no. An article on rootparenting.com was recently brought to my attention. It lists 5 reasons why time-outs are harmful to kids.

The whole write-up evokes the image of a dismissive parent angrily shaming their child off to their room at the first sign of ‘bad’ behavior. Paragraph after paragraph describes how time-outs lead to low self esteem, lack of trust, rebellion in the teen years, a kid’s inability to think for themselves, and just the general deterioration of your relationship. Finally, the author allows himself to admit the following:

Sure, you will need to let them simmer down from a tantrum or tears before discussing the issues they are having.

Um, bingo!

THAT is where a time-out sometimes helps, for our family. When Lil is worked up, beyond the ability to talk or listen. When she reaches that point, as long as she has an audience (me) she’ll continue to scream. That is when I bring her into her room for some much needed alone time to collect herself before discussion can start.

I tell her she needs to have a time-out until she is able to calm down enough to talk and listen. And then – I do what this article shuns – I walk away. But first, and this is key, I tell her, “come out when you’ve calmed down enough to talk.” I put the choice in her hands. She definitely screams a few moments more, but then does calm herself down and emerges when she is ready. And then I am very happy to see her, and we are able to move forward.

The article talks about separating ourselves from our kids as a horrific breach of trust that will have long-term affects on their self esteem. And it asserts that time-outs are disempowering for kids. But I find that this empowers Lil. She is able to calm herself down, in her own time. It is *her* choice to come out and join us with an adjusted attitude. Sometimes whatever had upset her is no longer an issue, because she was able to fix the problem herself. Often its something as simple as “i can’t get my doll to fit in her blanket the right way” and then I can help her out with that, and show her how to do it herself next time. Even if its still a debate, “i want to eat my lollipop right now” for instance, I’ll have a better chance of explaining to a non-screaming child that its too close to bedtime and she has already brushed her teeth.

These are the kinds of little things that can lead to a tantrum and sometimes she really does need a little alone time to gather herself before she can conversate. Yes my kid is not yet 3 but she talks like a 4yr old. The article further suggests that consequences are meaningless in kids under 5 because they have no understanding of things like sharing or of empathy. That’s a laugh. Sure there are exceptions to every ‘rule’ and I don’t doubt my daughter is among those.

I realize the underlying point of the article is to keep the open communicative relationship with our children; a message many parents should hear. Perhaps doctors and specialists on this matter should convey that better, without making the blanket assumption that timeouts are the lazy response of uncaring parents. A few more like this and I might start rolling my eyes at “attachment parenting” as one more phrase who’s meaning is muddled by preachy know-it-alls not open minded to the variables real-life parents deal with.

This entry was posted on Tuesday, March 16th, 2010 at 11:06 am and is filed under Li speaks, noticed on the net, trials and tribulations. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

There are currently 2 responses to “How Timeouts Sometimes Work for Us”

Why not let us know what you think by adding your own comment! Your opinion is as valid as anyone elses, so come on... let us know what you think.

  1. 1 On March 19th, 2010, Karen S said:

    Cor,

    So nicely written and well put. You are one awesome mom.

    And, yes, it’s a Friday night and I’m reading a blog about two year olds. Gotta do something to pass the time during these March Madness games.
    Miss you!
    -K

  2. 2 On March 22nd, 2010, corsakti said:

    thanks Karen!! :D

    I love the fact that some people actually read this occasionally, lol

Leave a Reply

Archives

Calendar

July 2014
S M T W T F S
« Jun    
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Recent


Subscribe!

Add to Google Reader or Homepage

To subscribe by email, enter your email address here:

and click:

Follow Me on Pinterest

Add to Technorati Favorites
Vote for my blog

Lil’ Twitter

    For more, follow Lilah Joy!
    You can also follow Lilah's mommy.